Monday, September 12, 2016

Berlin: A Conflicting Past

After watching Matt Frei's BBC Documentary about Berlin, I have been able to further understand
the city's prominence in Germany's history. A theme I found very prevalent throughout the film was that Berlin was a battleground, torn by many notions that would lead the city to what it is today. Frei
A portrait of Frederick the Great of Prussia
whose life strongly represents
 the history of Berlin
introduced us to Frederick the Great of Prussia and how he firmly represented Berlin. He stated, “To understand Frederick, is to understand Berlin” (Part 1; 5:06). At first, this statement left me confused. How can one person represent the ideal and history of an entire city? However, the farther in depth Frei went, the more it made sense.

Growing up, Frederick was surrounded by his family’s military traditions and way of life. He did as much as he could to steer away from it by having his tutors teach him classical poetry and the flute (Part 1; 9:45) and as he got older it became more noticeable that he possessed two very conflicting ways of life, torn between something so delicate and something very harsh. After the loss of the first World War the Kaiser renounced his throne and from that two republics were declared. One by the Chancellor’s deputy and the other by the communists (Part 2; 5:15). This caused much confusion among the people and the argument about who actually ruled began. Here we see two different ideologies clashing head to head in one city, much like in Frederick the Great's own life. 

The Schloss that was located in Berlin.
Home to many of Berlin's rulers, the
building was very important to the city.
This was the "Heart of Berlin"
Something that intrigued me was when Frei mentioned that even after all of these years after WWII and the unification of East and West Berlin “The act of demolition is as politically charged as the act of construction” (Part 5; 7:20). Soon after the war ended and the Communist Authorities took control over East Berlin, they decided that the Schloss, a royal palace that was home to Berlin rulers for centuries, needed to be torn down because with its imperial past it represented the wrong kind of history despite the fact that it was the “Heart of Berlin” (Part 5; 10:30). In it's place, a new building known as the Palace of the Republic which East Berlin used as the seat of the Parliament and an open
The Palace of the Republic. Seat of the East
Berlin Parliament and stood from 1973 to 2006
house for the people (Part 6; 5:35). The building was loved by many of the East Berliners despite the disagreement from the West. After standing since 1973, the Palace was once torn down to nothing but a plot of dirt in 2006. "When the Berlin Wall finally fell in 1989, the Palace of the Republic, a symbol of the communist east was never likely to survive in the reunited city" (Part 6; 7:25).  However, this was far from the most impactful construction in Berlin's past. 

In 1961, on a day know as "barbed wire Sunday," East Berlin authorities began construction on the Berlin Wall officially separating East and West Berlin. "When the wall was built it instantly became the most infamous and emotionally charged structure, not just in Berlin, but in the whole world" (Part 6; 2:38). Without fail, the wall spilt
Part of the Berlin Wall around the time it was being deconstructed.
everything in half including neighborhoods, families and the dead. This brought on strife and more competition from East and West Berlin with each side trying to construct the tallest building and further separating the two, but after the unification of East and West Berlin, the destruction of the wall in 1989 and the Palace of the Republic in 2006, there has been talk about whether or not a new Schloss should be built in the Palace's place, but there is disagreement from people throughout Berlin. Frei gave us an example when he sat down to talk with Berliners Heinrich Wulf and Sonja Schröter-Haacker. While Wulf thought that more than anything Berlin needed the Schloss to be rebuilt, Hacker could not disagree more. While disagreement about what should be built continues, the country is erecting "new old" buildings that acknowledge rather than deny the country's history. This could be very beneficial to the city as each side of the story is represented in one way or another. 

Word Count: 681


Works Cited:

Part 1-15 Berlin: Frei, Matt. “Berlin History – Dangerous Ideas”. YouTube. BBC, 27 Jan. 2011. Web. 08 Sept. 2016.  

Image Sources


Frederick the Great of Prussia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_the_Great

Palace of the Republic: http://www.dw.com/en/the-fall-of-berlins-palace-of-the-republic/a-18989016

Stadtschlosshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_Palace,_Berlin


No comments:

Post a Comment